Beyond Labels: Why Separating “Production” from “Mixing” Limits Your Creative Potential
Here's what I've noticed after years of working with mix engineers and producers: the moment you start drawing hard lines between production and mixing, you're already putting yourself in a box. Let's break down why this mindset might be holding you back and how to think about it differently.
The Traditional Divide Is Outdated
Think about your favorite records from the last five years. Can you clearly separate which decisions were "production" versus "mixing"? That massive 808 that defines the chorus – was that a production choice or a mixing decision? What about that vocal effect that transforms the bridge into something otherworldly?
The truth is, these labels come from an era when physical limitations of studios and technology forced us to work in distinct phases. But that's not our reality anymore.
Why This Separation Hurts Us
When we rigidly categorize our work as either production or mixing, we:
Miss Creative Opportunities: Some of the most innovative sonic moments happen when we blur these lines. Maybe that filter sweep you're hearing isn't just mixing – it's becoming part of the song's arrangement.
Limit Our Professional Growth: By labeling ourselves strictly as "just a mix engineer" or "just a producer," we might pass up chances to develop new skills and take on exciting projects.
Create Artificial Barriers: Sometimes we stop ourselves from making bold creative decisions because we think "that's not my role." This hesitation can prevent us from elevating a track to its full potential.
A Better Way to Think About It
Instead of asking "Is this production or mixing?" try asking:
"What does this song need right now?"
"How can I serve the artist's vision?"
"What would make this moment more impactful?"
Real-World Impact
I recently worked with a mix engineer who was hesitant to suggest arrangement changes because they saw themselves as "just the mixer." But when they started viewing their role more holistically, they began making suggestions that transformed tracks – moving sections around, adding new elements, even recording new parts.
The result? Their clients started seeing them as a more valuable creative partner, leading to more work and higher rates.
Practical Steps to Break Free
Expand Your Toolkit: Learn tools and techniques from both worlds. Understanding synthesis and sound design can make you a better mixer. Knowledge of precise automation and processing can make you a better producer.
Start Small: Next time you're mixing, if you hear an arrangement idea, speak up. Make it clear you're offering a suggestion while respecting the producer's role. Most collaborators appreciate thoughtful input.
Build Bridges: Connect with producers and other mix engineers. Understanding their perspectives and challenges will make you a better collaborator, regardless of your role.
Moving Forward
The future belongs to audio professionals who can adapt and bring value in multiple ways. Whether you primarily mix or produce, expanding your perspective beyond these traditional boundaries will make you more versatile and valuable to your clients.
Remember: at the end of the day, we're all trying to make great records. The labels we put on our roles matter far less than our ability to serve the music.
What matters is the impact we have on the final product – not the box we put ourselves in.
